Diego Santiago-Alarcon (santiagoalarcon@usf.edu), Pilar Carbó-Ramírez (pilarcarbo18@gmail.com), Gediminas Valkiūnas (gedvalk@ekoi.lt), Carine Brouat suggested: Gauthier Dobigny, gauthier.dobigny@ird.fr, Carine Brouat suggested: nathalie.charbonnel@inrae.fr, Benny Borremans suggested: Herwig Leirs - herwig.leirs@uantwerpen.be, Benny Borremans suggested: Joachim Mariën - joachim.marien@uantwerpen.be, Adele Mennerat suggested: I'm really sorry, I have conflict of interest (published with one of the coauthors in last 2 years). , Adele Mennerat suggested: You might try to ask Davide Dominioni in Saint Andrews or someone from his group. Or Erik Matthysen (he might have conflict of interest too with A. Charmantier, but perhaps someone from his group)., Adele Mennerat suggested: Wish I could help more! , Nathalie Charbonnel [nathalie.charbonnel@inrae.fr] suggested: Sorry, I am in the same lab than one of the coauthor. , Nathalie Charbonnel [nathalie.charbonnel@inrae.fr] suggested: Potential reviewers: , Nathalie Charbonnel [nathalie.charbonnel@inrae.fr] suggested: simone sommer Simone.Sommer@uni-ulm.de, Nathalie Charbonnel [nathalie.charbonnel@inrae.fr] suggested: Magalie Rene Martellet : magalie.renemartellet@vetagro-sup.fr, Nathalie Charbonnel [nathalie.charbonnel@inrae.fr] suggested: Maureen Murray maureenmurray@lpzoo.org, Gauthier Dobigny suggested: Florence Fournet (florence.fournet@ird.fr), Gauthier Dobigny suggested: Diego Ayala (diego.ayala@ird.fr), Andrés Visintín suggested: In their manuscript “Cities as parasitic amplifiers? Malaria prevalence and diversity in great tits along an urbanization gradient” Caizergues and co-authors report on the impact of urbanization on the prevalence and diversity of malaria parasites in two areas with different degree of anthropogenic disturbance, in Montpellier, France. , Andrés Visintín suggested: The manuscript is generally well-written and follow scientific convention. The introduction is nicely written and provides enough background information to support the relevance and interest of this study. Methods are also clear. Even though the results originally needed an expansion, this version provides much better information and analyses of the data obtained were deeply performed, and thus supporting the conclusions. , Andrés Visintín suggested: This will make a nice contribution to the body of literature regarding studies dealing with the urban ecology of host-parasite interactions. , Andrés Visintín suggested: In general, this is a much improved version of an earlier manuscript I revised, all my concerns were addressed, and I think it is a valuable contribution that merits publication.
No need for them to be recommenders of PCIEcology. Please do not suggest reviewers for whom there might be a conflict of interest. Reviewers are not allowed to review preprints written by close colleagues (with whom they have published in the last four years, with whom they have received joint funding in the last four years, or with whom they are currently writing a manuscript, or submitting a grant proposal), or by family members, friends, or anyone for whom bias might affect the nature of the review - see the code of conduct